The Centre for Solution Focused Practice

The therapist’s mindset. Evan George

This week I was leafing through my copy of More than Miracles (de Shazer et al., 2007) looking for something that I wanted for my teaching with another lovely group. And before too long I found it. I was trying to explain, or perhaps trying to find support for, my bold statement that everyone can answer the ‘best hopes’ (George et al., 1999) question. Indeed I might have said that I cannot remember the last person who could not answer the question normally within the first 10 minutes of a first session, but absolutely invariably during the first meeting, which is indeed the truth.

The piece that I was looking for reads as follows:

‘We think it makes a difference whether or not the therapist assumes that clients have the capacity to create meaningful descriptions of what they want their lives to look like and how they want to be in the world. Asking the miracle question both implies and demands faith in the client's capacity to do this and the question needs to be asked in a manner that communicates this faith.

When asking the miracle question, or teaching the concept in training seminars, we have learned that the way you ask the question is very important, i.e., you have to ask the question as if you really want to hear the answer and you believe the client has the ability to give a good answer.’

And then, a few lines later, the authors state:

‘If we believe that a client has the capacity to describe a problem then we must also believe that he or she is capable of describing what “better” than that problem would be.’ (de Shazer et al., 2007, p 39)

I agree. The therapist’s belief in the client’s capacity is vital. If the therapist doubts, then when the client responds to the best hopes question with ‘I don’t know’ which I think is probably the most common first response then the risk is that the worker will assume that this means that the client will not be able to answer, typically within minutes. If workers ‘believe’ then they will respond in a way that will elicit an answer. Indeed in my view a response is vital since without a response I would not know what to focus on in the session, I would have no starting point for the conversation. I would be left with a client in the room and no where to go and that would be embarrassing (for me anyway).

And the last line I think is important. If we believe that the client is capable of describing the problem then why would we doubt the client’s capacity to answer the ‘best hopes’ question and very few practitioners doubt the client’s capacity to describe the problem!

By the way it is also interesting to note how so many of us in the field end up saying very similar things. I always say that the question ‘what else . . . ?’ must convey to the client both our interest and our belief in the client’s capacity to find another answer. After all if we were to ask a question not believing in the client’s capacity then that would be tantamount to setting up the client to fail. And that would be an act of unkindness if not of cruelty.

de Shazer, Steve, Dolan, Yvonne, Korman, Harry, Trepper, Terry, MacCollum, Eric and Berg, Insoo Kim (2007) More Then Miracles: the state of the art of solution focused therapy. New York: Haworth.

George, Evan, Iveson, Chris, and Ratner, Harvey (2nd edition, 1999) Problem to Solution: brief therapy with individuals and families. London: BT Press.

Evan George

London

18th October 2026

Archives

Featured Video

What is SF - a 2020 version of the approach

Image

July 9, 2020